New Novel - Any feedback. The Ascendants: Early Years – Lightning, Fire, Shadows… and Brotherhood

PandaKen07

New member
Joined
Apr 7, 2025
Messages
19
Points
3
Hello guys!
I’ve been working hard revising and improving my novel “The Ascendants: Early Years”, and I’m hoping to get your honest feedback and thoughts on it!

This is a story about three young boys who are destined to become legends, trained by a mysterious master and thrown into a world filled with mana beasts, magic, and danger. Think fantasy meets anime energy… with some inspiration from "The Shield" yep, that Shield from WWE.

 

StoneInky

Heart of Stone, Head of Ink
Joined
Jun 24, 2024
Messages
445
Points
108
First Impression:

A huge block of text is the first thing I see in the synopsis. It's very intimidating. Turn into multiple paragraphs, please.

And you're not telling us what is special about your story. It's about an assassin guy doing martial arts stuff, or so I assume from the tags? And there's a Camelot theme going on, too. Then that's what the synopsis should focus on.

Strange powers, unexplained identity, epic tale of courage and self discovery, resilience and sacrifice, that is every single fantasy novel out there. You don't need to say that, because we already know. And we don't want to read several sentences about something we already know. It's generic, tasteless mop, reading as if it were written by AI.


Thoughts on the Story:

I went into chapter one, and was immidiately hit with the words 'prologue.' Choose. Is it the prologue, or the first chapter?

If the two are combined, seperate them. I hope that's what happened, and it was just a mistake— I only see a glimpse of the protagonist in 'A Sudden Awakening', and that' what feels like the real beginning of the chapter.

More importantly, the story screams it was written by AI.

The overused em-dash was the biggest indicator for me. The keyboard does not have the em-dash key, and AI often use em as a catch-all tool for tone shifts I'm not sure if it is, but I don't care if the answer is yes. It saps all my want to read.

The story feels like it was written by you, but you ran it through AI to make it sound 'better'. Sadly, AI is not a perfect tool. It cleaned up your story pacing, and added little descriptions, but it also sapped any semblence of unique passion from your writing. The tone, the feel you were going for, the core ideas of your story, they were all killed.

It's as if you tried to make a delicious meal, but messed everything up. Then you asked the AI to salvage it. So the AI blended it and made it look pretty. But the result is unedible. It may look pretty, but it's mixed with dirt and debris.

Without AI, it wasn't the prettiest, but at least it was edible.
 
Last edited:

PandaKen07

New member
Joined
Apr 7, 2025
Messages
19
Points
3
First Impression:

A huge block of text is the first thing I see in the synopsis. It's very intimidating. Turn into multiple paragraphs, please.

And you're not telling us what is special about your story. It's about an assassin guy doing martial arts stuff, or so I assume from the tags? And there's a Camelot theme going on, too. Then that's what the synopsis should focus on.

Strange powers, unexplained identity, epic tale of courage and self discovery, resilience and sacrifice, that is every single fantasy novel out there. You don't need to say that, because we already know. And we don't want to read several sentences about something we already know. It's generic, tasteless mop, reading as if it were written by AI.


Thoughts on the Story:

I went into chapter one, and was immidiately hit with the words 'prologue.' Choose. Is it the prologue, or the first chapter?

If the two are combined, seperate them. I hope that's what happened, and it was just a mistake— I only see a glimpse of the protagonist in 'A Sudden Awakening', and that' what feels like the real beginning of the chapter.

More importantly, the story screams it was written by AI.

The overused em-dash was the biggest indicator for me. The keyboard does not have the em-dash key, and AI often use em as a catch-all tool for tone shifts I'm not sure if it is, but I don't care if the answer is yes. It saps all my want to read.

The story feels like it was written by you, but you ran it through AI to make it sound 'better'. Sadly, AI is not a perfect tool. It cleaned up your story pacing, and added little descriptions, but it also sapped any semblence of unique passion from your writing. The tone, the feel you were going for, the core ideas of your story, they were all killed.

It's as if you tried to make a delicious meal, but messed everything up. Then you asked the AI to salvage it. So the AI blended it and made it look pretty. But the result is unedible. It may look pretty, but it's mixed with dirt and debris.

Without AI, it wasn't the prettiest, but at least it was edible.
Thank you for your feedback! It honestly makes me happy knowing someone took the time to read and respond to my story. I really appreciate your thoughts.

I understand where you're coming from. You probably have a lot of experience as both a writer and reader, while I’m still an amateur, currently a university student just writing in my free time.

About the em-dashes, yeah, I mainly use them for strong tone shifts or sudden interruptions. I write most of my drafts using Microsoft Word on my phone, especially during breaks or downtime. My laptop also has Word, but it doesn’t give me quick access to em-dashes like my phone does. That’s why they might pop up more often than intended.

I get that some parts of my writing might feel AI-like, but I assure you, It’s all me. I’m still learning and doing my best to improve the tone, pacing, and emotional weight with every chapter.

And for synopsis means — a brief summary or general survey of something, I just give a summary of my story, that's all.

As for the “prologue,” that one’s on me. I originally wrote it as a glimpse into future events, kind of inspired by how Solo Leveling started. But I get now that it may have caused confusion, so I’ll separate it properly from Chapter 1 moving forward.

This story draws inspiration from Solo Leveling, God of War, Monkey King Movie and even The Shield from WWE. I wanted to create a world where mythologies collide, and every fairy tale story , every history, and every god exists into one like Marvel Universe. Artreus, my main character, is still on the path of discovering who he really is.

My vision was to drop readers into a war they don’t fully understand at first, just like life. The idea is that the truth and deeper meaning are revealed through the journey. I know that might be confusing at times, so feel free to let me know which parts were unclear, I’d really appreciate that kind of feedback.


Thanks again. I'm grateful you gave my story a shot. I’ll keep improving!
First Impression:

A huge block of text is the first thing I see in the synopsis. It's very intimidating. Turn into multiple paragraphs, please.

And you're not telling us what is special about your story. It's about an assassin guy doing martial arts stuff, or so I assume from the tags? And there's a Camelot theme going on, too. Then that's what the synopsis should focus on.

Strange powers, unexplained identity, epic tale of courage and self discovery, resilience and sacrifice, that is every single fantasy novel out there. You don't need to say that, because we already know. And we don't want to read several sentences about something we already know. It's generic, tasteless mop, reading as if it were written by AI.


Thoughts on the Story:

I went into chapter one, and was immidiately hit with the words 'prologue.' Choose. Is it the prologue, or the first chapter?

If the two are combined, seperate them. I hope that's what happened, and it was just a mistake— I only see a glimpse of the protagonist in 'A Sudden Awakening', and that' what feels like the real beginning of the chapter.

More importantly, the story screams it was written by AI.

The overused em-dash was the biggest indicator for me. The keyboard does not have the em-dash key, and AI often use em as a catch-all tool for tone shifts I'm not sure if it is, but I don't care if the answer is yes. It saps all my want to read.

The story feels like it was written by you, but you ran it through AI to make it sound 'better'. Sadly, AI is not a perfect tool. It cleaned up your story pacing, and added little descriptions, but it also sapped any semblence of unique passion from your writing. The tone, the feel you were going for, the core ideas of your story, they were all killed.

It's as if you tried to make a delicious meal, but messed everything up. Then you asked the AI to salvage it. So the AI blended it and made it look pretty. But the result is unedible. It may look pretty, but it's mixed with dirt and debris.

Without AI, it wasn't the prettiest, but at least it was edible.
I truly hope you continue reading. I know I still have a lot to learn, but I’m doing my best to grow as a writer.=D
 
Last edited:

StoneInky

Heart of Stone, Head of Ink
Joined
Jun 24, 2024
Messages
445
Points
108
Ok
Thank you for your feedback! It honestly makes me happy knowing someone took the time to read and respond to my story. I really appreciate your thoughts.

I understand where you're coming from. You probably have a lot of experience as both a writer and reader, while I’m still an amateur, currently a university student just writing in my free time.

About the em-dashes, yeah, I mainly use them for strong tone shifts or sudden interruptions. I write most of my drafts using Microsoft Word on my phone, especially during breaks or downtime. My laptop also has Word, but it doesn’t give me quick access to em-dashes like my phone does. That’s why they might pop up more often than intended.

I get that some parts of my writing might feel AI-like, but I assure you, It’s all me. I’m still learning and doing my best to improve the tone, pacing, and emotional weight with every chapter.

And for synopsis means — a brief summary or general survey of something, I just give a summary of my story, that's all.

As for the “prologue,” that one’s on me. I originally wrote it as a glimpse into future events, kind of inspired by how Solo Leveling started. But I get now that it may have caused confusion, so I’ll separate it properly from Chapter 1 moving forward.

This story draws inspiration from Solo Leveling, God of War, Monkey King Movie and even The Shield from WWE. I wanted to create a world where mythologies collide, and every fairy tale story , every history, and every god exists into one like Marvel Universe. Artreus, my main character, is still on the path of discovering who he really is.

My vision was to drop readers into a war they don’t fully understand at first, just like life. The idea is that the truth and deeper meaning are revealed through the journey. I know that might be confusing at times, so feel free to let me know which parts were unclear, I’d really appreciate that kind of feedback.


Thanks again. I'm grateful you gave my story a shot. I’ll keep improving.

Yeah, that's nice. I guess I was wrong. Hm... maybe I'm just more paranoid nowadays due to seeing more AI generated writing everywhere.

In that case, although your writing hasn't gotten any better, I still have a better opinion of it. Because human writing can improve, but AI writing cannot. I'll try to think on why the story tastes a bit... weird.

Em-dashes were one thing. The other one was all the short sentences. I like short sentences, but I also like longer ones, with more description. AI has this habit of turning all the sentences short when it wants to sound fast paced and 'action-y', and it looks like you do, too. To fix that, you don't have to turn all the sentences long, just make sure it doesn't read so childishly.

That, and all the sound effects. Another thing AI does when it wants to make things sound explosive and important. But it doesn't really work. There's too many of them, and they are all over the place. Even if this is your style of writing and prose, you want to not overdo it. Right now, the sound effects are interrupting almost every moment in the story. I can't read.

Oh, and don't take my review too seriously, lmao. I'm also just doing things in my free time. We're similar age. Good luck, I hope you find lots of readers.
 
Last edited:

PandaKen07

New member
Joined
Apr 7, 2025
Messages
19
Points
3
Ok


Yeah, that's nice. I guess I was wrong. Hm... maybe I'm just more paranoid nowadays due to seeing more AI generated writing everywhere.

In that case, although your writing hasn't gotten any better, I still have a better opinion of it. Because human writing can improve, but AI writing cannot. I'll try to think on why the story tastes a bit... weird.

Em-dashes were one thing. The other one was all the short sentences. I like short sentences, but I also like longer ones, with more description. AI has this habit of turning all the sentences short when it wants to sound fast paced and 'action-y', and it looksl like you do, too. To fix that, you don't have to turn them all the sentences long, just make sure it doesn't read so childishly.

That, and all the sound effects. Another thing AI does when it wants to make things sound explosive and important. But it doesn't really work. There's too many of them, and they are all over the place. Even if this is your style of writing and prose, you want to not overdo it. Right now, the sound effects are interrupting almost every moment in the story. I can't read.

Oh, and don't take my review too seriously, lmao. I'm also just doing things in my free time. We're similar age. Good luck, I hope you find lots of readers.
Thanks for the follow-up, I appreciate it a lot. And honestly, no worries!

AI stuff, It’s everywhere now, and I’ve read stories where the tone just feels... off. So I’m actually glad you took the time to clarify.

I know my writing still has a long way to go, and I’m not afraid to admit that. But hearing you recognize it as human writing means more than you might think. Like you said, human writing can grow.

You're absolutely right about the short sentences and sound effects. I’ve been leaning into a more action-heavy style with anime-inspired pacing and stylized flair, but yeah, I definitely overdid it in some places. I’ll work on balancing things better—mixing short and long sentences, adding richer descriptions, and like back the BAMMs, SWOOSHHES, and CRACKKLES when they’re not needed.

I was mostly following the style I’ve seen in some Webnovel stories. lots of Sound effects during battles. My intention was to help readers visualize the action more in a way that produces powerful feelings or strong, clear images in the mind, but I get that too much can actually pull you out of the scene.

This kind of feedback is exactly what helps me improve, so thank you again. And hey! it’s cool knowing we’re around the same age and both writing in our free time. We’re all just trying to get better, one story at a time.

Looking forward to hearing more of your thoughts if you keep reading!
 
Top