I'd love a review (or two)

RavensQuill

Every great story needs an author
Joined
Jun 19, 2020
Messages
135
Points
83
Hey all. I've been on this site damn near *checks watch* 5 years, and been a serial fiction writer for going on 6. I've only recently been hit with the realization that it doesn't matter how good my writing is, I just need to get it in front of as many eyes as I can. (granted, I know it has to be good to keep readers).

So let's do some shoutout swaps, if you don't mind. Also, an honest opinion (in the form of a review) on the first 4-5 chapters would be SUPER appreciated. I will, of course, be more than happy to return the favor.

But yeah, please check out my newest story and tell me what you think!
 

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,695
Points
113
I took a quick look at your profile, and well, congratulations! You've been a member of this site for five years.

However, I also noticed that during those five years, you haven't really studied trends. One example is the simple packaging of your novel covers. I don't know if you have a specific principle or if it's just a habit. But if you study and are willing to apply trends to your fiction, perhaps you could package your fiction with anime or light novel-style covers. I'm sure your engagement would be better if it were packaged more appropriately in line with trends.
 

RavensQuill

Every great story needs an author
Joined
Jun 19, 2020
Messages
135
Points
83
I took a quick look at your profile, and well, congratulations! You've been a member of this site for five years.

However, I also noticed that during those five years, you haven't really studied trends. One example is the simple packaging of your novel covers. I don't know if you have a specific principle or if it's just a habit. But if you study and are willing to apply trends to your fiction, perhaps you could package your fiction with anime or light novel-style covers. I'm sure your engagement would be better if it were packaged more appropriately in line with trends.
Yeah, I've been around a while now xD

I will not, however, change from the carefully curated/planned covers that showcase the theme of my story for a cute anime character that has very little/nothing to do with the story or serves as clickbait. I just need eyes on (which I can get through shoutout swaps), and then the readers will see the quality of my story and (hopefully) stick around :)

Thanks for the tip and engagement <3
 

FRWriter

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 3, 2024
Messages
567
Points
108
I'll give it a read. However, while I usually prefer longer stories, you have completed so many in the past, so the fear of it getting dropped is quite low. I like that a lot.
 

Worthy39

The protagonist's third cousin, twice removed
Joined
Aug 6, 2025
Messages
638
Points
93
I took a quick look at your profile, and well, congratulations! You've been a member of this site for five years.

However, I also noticed that during those five years, you haven't really studied trends. One example is the simple packaging of your novel covers. I don't know if you have a specific principle or if it's just a habit. But if you study and are willing to apply trends to your fiction, perhaps you could package your fiction with anime or light novel-style covers. I'm sure your engagement would be better if it were packaged more appropriately in line with trends.
They didn't ask for a cover review, they asked for a story review... besides, not everyone can get those styles of covers made, or make them themselves. And using AI is something not everyone wants to do. People write on here for fun, not usually as a professional, meaning they don't have the money to buy it from someone else. I see this in literally every every writing thread you post in... it's not an art thread.
 

DismaiNaim

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2024
Messages
188
Points
83
They didn't ask for a cover review, they asked for a story review... besides, not everyone can get those styles of covers made, or make them themselves. And using AI is something not everyone wants to do. People write on here for fun, not usually as a professional, meaning they don't have the money to buy it from someone else. I see this in literally every every writing thread you post in... it's not an art thread.
Makes me wonder if the next thing will be them saying how much they love the story and they have some ideas for art...
 

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,695
Points
113
They didn't ask for a cover review, they asked for a story review... besides, not everyone can get those styles of covers made, or make them themselves. And using AI is something not everyone wants to do. People write on here for fun, not usually as a professional, meaning they don't have the money to buy it from someone else. I see this in literally every every writing thread you post in... it's not an art thread.
I know that. That's why my comment said:

"However, I also noticed that during those five years, you haven't really studied trends. One example is the simple packaging of your novel covers. I don't know if you have a specific principle or if it's just a habit."

I admit that having 'principles' for fiction can be a reason not to follow trends. And here's the main problem: if the story has good engagement, then feedback will come naturally even without the author asking. Meanwhile, fiction that is packaged as is tends to get less attention from readers.

So, like it or not, packaging is still important if you want your story to get organic feedback. But if your fiction is just a hobby or read by yourself, then any packaging is no longer relevant.
 

DismaiNaim

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2024
Messages
188
Points
83
You asked for a few chapters, I read through about halfway through the second before I just got bored. I was bored in the first but pushed through hoping it would get better.

There's no conflict. No tension. No stakes.

You have the party going through the dungeon for no apparent reason killing goblins that pose no threat. That about sums up everything I read so far.

There's no setting. It wasn't until the very end of chapter 1 when you revealed this was a volcano dungeon, and even after that nothing about the place says "volcano"

All your characters feel flat. I couldn't tell one from another except Marina, your only female character, who follows a list of female stereotypes rather than any actual characterizations.

Please forgive me if this is too harsh, but that's what I see. I was going to leave a review on your page but I don't think my review is going to help drive traffic
 

RavensQuill

Every great story needs an author
Joined
Jun 19, 2020
Messages
135
Points
83
I'll give it a read. However, while I usually prefer longer stories, you have completed so many in the past, so the fear of it getting dropped is quite low. I like that a lot.
I assure you, the chance is non-existant xD I never drop stories. If I don't like where one's going, I find a natural conclusion.
You asked for a few chapters, I read through about halfway through the second before I just got bored. I was bored in the first but pushed through hoping it would get better.

There's no conflict. No tension. No stakes.

You have the party going through the dungeon for no apparent reason killing goblins that pose no threat. That about sums up everything I read so far.

There's no setting. It wasn't until the very end of chapter 1 when you revealed this was a volcano dungeon, and even after that nothing about the place says "volcano"

All your characters feel flat. I couldn't tell one from another except Marina, your only female character, who follows a list of female stereotypes rather than any actual characterizations.

Please forgive me if this is too harsh, but that's what I see. I was going to leave a review on your page but I don't think my review is going to help drive traffic
That's still actionable feedback I can use! If you'd read on a little longer, you'd have seen that it was an entrance exam of sorts, but I can see about possibly tightening that up for future readers. Thank you for your input :)
 

melchi

What is a custom title?
Joined
May 2, 2021
Messages
2,880
Points
153
You asked for a few chapters, I read through about halfway through the second before I just got bored. I was bored in the first but pushed through hoping it would get better.

There's no conflict. No tension. No stakes.

You have the party going through the dungeon for no apparent reason killing goblins that pose no threat. That about sums up everything I read so far.

There's no setting. It wasn't until the very end of chapter 1 when you revealed this was a volcano dungeon, and even after that nothing about the place says "volcano"

All your characters feel flat. I couldn't tell one from another except Marina, your only female character, who follows a list of female stereotypes rather than any actual characterizations.

Please forgive me if this is too harsh, but that's what I see. I was going to leave a review on your page but I don't think my review is going to help drive traffic
This,

Could use some more work on the hook. The synopsis says something about Grim setting out and something big is going to happen but it is so vague. Gotta answer "Why should I read this?" to readers in the first chapter.
 

Sylver

Writer/Lover of Monster Girl Smut Content <3
Joined
Oct 11, 2023
Messages
577
Points
133
Hmm, a quick glimpse at your work and I've a few comments. I like the cover art, it's pretty and stands out a bit for me, mostly because the common cover art is anime inspired x) and your cover looks like actual art I would see from a bookstore.

I can read into your stories individually, see what they can use. Or did you want feedback on your newest story only? Some of your work is completed after all.
 

RavensQuill

Every great story needs an author
Joined
Jun 19, 2020
Messages
135
Points
83
Hmm, a quick glimpse at your work and I've a few comments. I like the cover art, it's pretty and stands out a bit for me, mostly because the common cover art is anime inspired x) and your cover looks like actual art I would see from a bookstore.

I can read into your stories individually, see what they can use. Or did you want feedback on your newest story only? Some of your work is completed after all.
The newest story, please: "A Grand Quest". And if you could, please offer that feedback in a review. I originally wanted shoutouts to swap with people, but a review could be helpful as well :)

Thanks for your time
This,

Could use some more work on the hook. The synopsis says something about Grim setting out and something big is going to happen but it is so vague. Gotta answer "Why should I read this?" to readers in the first chapter.
A. Synopsis is supposed to be a vague hint at what happens in the book.
B. You can choose your "why" from the description itself, which I (as the author who has read past the first 2-3 chapters) know is accurate. If it doesn't appeal... I could look into fixing that, though not sure why.
C/Bonus Point. Might just be directed at what you quoted, but I'm sleep-deprived. The first few chapters of a book are supposed to be introductory in nature. There shouldn't be any action resembling a climax.
 

FleecedSheep

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 26, 2023
Messages
52
Points
58
Well, I'm not looking for a review swap or anything, but I do want to give some advice.

I went ahead and read the first two chapters, I know it's not a lot, but I noticed something pretty quick. You're writing is unmoored, you don't take the time to establish the settings of exactly where the person is, and consequently, it makes it look like you didn't put much thought in it either.

Like an above poster stated, setting the stakes. There was a throwaway line in the first chapter about being in an exam. A good chance to elaborate on the setting would have been the character dismissing the chest because it wasn't worth the bother, since it wouldn't earn any points. Whereas, the goblins would. That alone sets the stakes, specifically being, that the character needs points for the exam.

This could have been reiterated by the characters decision to engage with the goblins later on. Which you kinda did.

As for the setting, you need to engage the senses. Right now, it feels like you're just telling the reader what to see and not giving the reader time to process what is available and make inferences and judgements on their own. Like, at the end of the chapter there is a throwaway line that he's in a volcano dungeon, and yet nothing up to this point gave me the idea he was in anything other than a normal dungeon.

You could start the chapter with something like, The heat was oppressive. Pressing in from all sides, even just sneaking around was a chore as his sweat soaked into his clothes. His lips were constantly dry, and every breath made his tongue wither from the heat. Only constant sips of cool water that wet his tongue and throat kept him feeling alive.

Engage the senses. what does the dungeon smell like? If it's a volcano dungeon, does it smell like brimstone? Sulfur? Where is the light coming from? You said torches, but that isn't implied until you told us during the boss fight. At the time, with how dim it was, I thought the lighting was from lava that was running through the walls or something. Which would contribute to the heat and also would make for a good reason for why the lighting is so dim at times.

My biggest pet peeve was the fight scene, you made it obvious that targeting the big guy was the best option, but why? You never established the field of battle. There were three goblins, but what was their formation? Their equipment? How tall are they? All these add to the moment, and wouldn't they be hot too? Or they adapted to the heat?

A proper breakdown would have gone something like,

'There were three goblins. He knew he could take them, only how. One was trailing behind, the bigger of the trio. Clearly, they must have been the boss, or at least the one that gave orders among the three. The other two were further ahead, one had a spear, the other a sword and shield. As for armor? All they had were rags. Fighting them all at once would be trouble. Each was about half his size, so, he knew he could overpower them one on one, but he needed to avoid getting hurt to maximize his point gains. Which meant, he needed to whittle down their numbers.

In a matter of seconds, a plan formed and he moved, the answer was obvious. With a leap, his daggers punched into the rear goblin's back. The wet squelch of cold steel meeting hot flesh just loud enough to alert the pair ahead. By the time they turned, he'd already retrieved his daggers. Before either could move, he kicked the dying goblin into the sword and shield wielding goblin whom went down with an aborted squawk.

He didn't stop. The moment he kicked the dying goblin, his feet were already in motion. By the time the dying goblin hit, he was already before the spear wielding goblin. Terrified and shocked by his sudden motion, the goblin made a hasty thrust, the spear tip missing by a mile, and cold steel found its home in the goblin's throat.

With a twist, he retrieved the blade and rounded on the sword and shield wielding goblin, who had just barely managed to get out from under his now dead companion.

He grinned, the short burst of activity had him parched, and his brow was wet with sweat, but it was all worth it. With a jolt he went forward, the goblin swung wide with their sword, attempting to stop him, but he easily dodged and snuck in, his blade swung down, carving into the goblin's arm, the cold edge cutting along bone, not quite cutting through, but definitely disarmed the goblin.

Now disarmed, the goblin wasn't an issue. All too easily, he finished it off and looked over the battlefield. Taking an idle sip of his canteen, he couldn't wait for this exam to be done.'

Or, uh, something like that, it's not written well. Establish where they are, the stakes, and use it. The more established a scene is the more you can do with it, the more dynamic it can feel. The more an audience can anticipate what's happening during the fight. Which makes the fight more, fun.

As for the party members, I mean, yeah, they're not memorable, but have their banter revolve around the conditions of the dungeon. Have the girl complain about the heal, and possibly how its drying out her hair, making it frizz, or something. The tank has to be absolutely miserable, if he's wearing heavy armor in a hot setting, he's gotta be stewing in his sweat. I wouldn't wanna be around when he takes those boots off. Having him mention that and his wish to just get this done and over with would make sense, plus it would add to the setting. As for the final guy, honestly? No idea.

You should have established what the boss area looks like, you had a chance when the main character was scouting it out. A general idea of the numbers and what the leader is wielding, wearing, so on. Even the size and design of the area would have been nice to know. I was convinced the boss was an ogre or something, but they're a goblin boss and that, confused me. Like, how big is he? How could he be big enough to squash a grown man when a goblin is typically on the smaller side, unless otherwise stated. As for the fight itself, honestly, the whole boss fight I was just lost. I was just kind of along for the ride and that wasn't a good thing.

I had to admit, the main character has me interested. They seem to know what they are doing and clearly aren't shy about killing. A lot of those strikes he made weren't something just anyone could do, especially when knives can easily get caught on ribs or something like that. made me wonder where he got that kind of training, because there's no way he's just a random nobody.

Your first chapter could be a decent hook, but you need to actually hook people. Get them into the moment, let them feel what the main character is feeling in the moment. Establish the setting so people aren't just, floating in the wind and go from there.

I'm not sure how qualified I am to be giving advice like this, I've not been around as long as you. I've only got one completed story under my belt and it sucks, and though my currently posting story is leagues better, I don't think its that great. So, take my advice with a grain of salt. See how it works for you, and well, hopefully nothing I said offends.

If I overstepped at all, sorry. Otherwise, I do hope this helps.
 
Top