I generally avoid novels with Romance in their genre

CheertheSecond

The second coming of CheertheDead
Joined
Nov 15, 2022
Messages
1,512
Points
153
I am ok with those that have romance as subplot. When romance isn't the focus, the character relationship unfolded much more natural. Meanwhile, in romance genre, I can taste the deliberation in the author's writing to make a set of characters into couples. It feels really distasteful and is the most glaringly terrible impression.
 

FieryLou

Phoeperor of the Phoenix Race.
Joined
Apr 18, 2025
Messages
212
Points
63
download.jpeg
 

zephyrtrillian

Active member
Joined
Jun 16, 2025
Messages
75
Points
33
I feel like if someone is putting "romance" as a tag, then I expect it to take up a significant part of the story. I'm with you; I avoid them. If a little bit of romance ends up being in the story, I don't mind, but I don't want it to be the main focus.

Some level of experience/skill/thoughtfulness is necessary to properly create romantic tension that puts me on the edge of my seat, and I find that that happens more to me if I have gotten invested in the characters and their story rather than just whether these two strangers are going to kiss.
 

Cookiez_N_Potionz

Rank: Moon Leo
Joined
Sep 27, 2024
Messages
425
Points
78
Than you might like my story?

 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,736
Points
158
About once every two or three years I'll pick up a romance (my wife had quite a few scattered around the house before we did a big book donation and she got rid of all the ones she could remember more than two plot points in - this meaning she either "read it but it didn't stick" or she "started it and lost interest" and thus it was one she could part with), just to see how far I can put up with it. If the characters are interesting, that's "all the way" - I made it through about 3/4 of them... Too often the characters are cookie cutter copies of each other, with only the environment different from one story to the next. The few authors who actually put some effort into it put out some decent work, but most ... well, might as well be AI (from what I gather, in the 70s-90s, at least a couple of publishers would "test out" new authors by assigning them romances with a checklist of things they had to include; if they put out something that could sell decently, then the publisher would read their proposals and forward them to the proper division; if they couldn't put together a romance that could sell, they were deemed unable to make anything sellable - and, of course, if they put out a best-seller, they would be "stuck" in the romance department but allowed to use their real name or a pen name of their choice instead of the house name their first novel went out under).

As an aside, there was at least one publisher who had series novels set aside for new authors - TV tie-ins like Star Trek and ongoing serial fiction would be their testing grounds for authors who would not or could not do romance. Still did the "one test novel in that line" thing like the romance ones did, and were more likely to keep writers in those lines if they sold at all (I get the impression that was how the late Peter David got started, before he sold his first comic book script and then got to know enough people in the industry to submit proposals to the people who would approve them rather than to the "gatekeepers")
 

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,751
Points
113
My novel explicitly warns on the front page,

Trigger Warning:
"...It contains no fan service, light romance, or harem."

Because I want my story to be driven by its central moral premise (the mother-daughter relationship and universal human values in a dark world), and I don't want to mislead new readers who come looking for romance between the characters.
 

OniKaniki

Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2025
Messages
62
Points
18
Sadly, romance was one of the most popular tags out there, so for better visibility, authors often put up the romance tag in there, even though their story has little to do with romance.
 
Top