Search results

Thats portal fantasy if he has that ability. I thought it was earlier argued by the mob that being trapped or having a minimal level of difficultt in returning home was a key component? And what does all of this have to do with the concept of amnesia creating a new being and that being a...

That's the same universe, just a different planet. Why are you contradicting yourself now? I though it was argued that "world" meant a new dimension. And the other planets in the same universe aren't isekai? Or is stargate an isekai again? Nope I wish. The trans activists really hate me lol...

Most of the authors on scribblehub are bad authors lol. They'll one star in retribution just for your politics. Total snowflakes. I faced all rebuttals. Aside from you, because you replied about some farmboy reincarnated thing I never talked about. Most people here I just backed into a corner...

Perhaps of its not simply used to escape having any kid of backstory, and shows true amnesia and not comical amnesia as we see in stories and soap operas. I have yet to any such story though.

Galileo was oppressed for being correct as well. The self righteousness among is laughable. Amnesia of any kind defeats the entire purpose of the isekai genre period. Nothing will change my mind.

It wasn't even me that posted it. Two years old from someone else. But it's nice of you to make assumptions. Makes you look like an ass.

I can prove you wrong easily and simply. A guy gets isekaied with everything but his name due to amnesia. He was Richard the 2nd, and intended to name his first born son Richard the 3rd. Now he names his son something totally different because he forgot his name. Different actions taken when...

The funniest part is that the ceespit of reddit actually agrees with me more than everyone here disagrees, at least when it comes to amnesia and isekai. Found a post of savage divinity being ripped on for this exact issue.

They just get combined after editing for typos, but wait is " sadge" a whole sentence by itself?, ehh whatever we roll!

Keep going it needs to make another lap around the house. 2 sentences 2 shots. I'm gonna regret this in the morning.

Uh huh sure whatever, I'm honestly not reading anything you post just taking shots with my buddies to see how long you rant for. Keep going please.

You avoided my question. Please explain the difference from the readers perspective. No it isn't because ANOTHER world requires there to have been a previous. Without the prior world its not ANOTHER. You know, the first half the definition of isekai? Furthermore it doesn't have to be...

Sense of self is a culmination of all memories naturally ratianed through life. Something as simple as forgetting your name can lead to making decisions you wouldn't normally which proves that your are not the same person. Thus if you lose any memories for any real length of time you are not the...

??? you do realize that you are simply making yourself look like a fool at worst or troll at a best by not replying in good faith correct? Wait, are you a butthurt amnesia-Kai author?

I didn't say anything about reincarnation as a farmer. Go reread whatever you think you read. It does because amnesia is personality death of the first entity to make room for the second. If the first never exists in the new world how is it isekai? If my mind was wipped and my body while still...

You haven't added anything at all. All you did was reply to a comment not even meant for you at all. While giving a non Answer. Its like you can't even realize that if a farm boy has amnesia he isn't a farm boy anymore. That's a special kind of stupid. Oh and insults. That's a thing for when...

Says the reply that doesn't wven have the balls to give me an honest answer because they know I'm correct. Functionally they are both the same because the reader experiences the world the same. In this comparison the isekai genre adds nothing, and that's the reason why amnesia and isekai simply...

A plot device that kills the isekaied person via personality death. Which defeats the entire purpose of the isekai genre. You can't be isekaied if your sense of self is deleted or repressed. Not only does a foreign personality develop but when memories are regained it doesn't bring the isekaied...

The point is they aren't the same person from their ending on one world to their life in the next. Without that, it's not the same person and not isekai. I work with the elderly with alzhiemers, and I can guarantee that they aren't the same person from moment to moment. They change based on the...

The damage is. When they are regained they aren't the same person meaning nobody was isekaied at all. Once they are lost for any real period of time, a new personality develops that those memories are added ontop of, not replacing. The anime Golden time touches on this very well. Read the...