abysslover12
New member
- Joined
- Dec 20, 2025
- Messages
- 12
- Points
- 3
First of all,I'll be honest and maybe a little harsh.
First, your prologue is like any mainstream Chinese manhua or novel I've ever read. It's very typical... a protagonist with a sick (and then deceased) family member and a cheating lover.
I understand you might want to create a tragic and complex protagonist. But this kind of plot feels cheap... some people will be immediately allergic to the NTR element in the prologue.
A prologue is supposed to provide a hook for new readers to connect with your fiction. Presenting NTR drama like this might hurt readers and turn them away, rather than making them applaud.
So, your conflict is too cheap - it might be harsh, but I don't like prologues like this either. Can you create a more human and dignified MC character, even if it's tragic?
In this case, I appreciate manhwa that present more human drama and MC. Try reading manhwa and comparing it with manhua to see the differences. Maybe you'll find a better formula for designing a human, even if tragic MC.
Second, from a writing perspective... your chapter is full of long dialogues. Honestly, I had a hard time identifying who was speaking, especially since you introduced three characters without any introduction—and immediately launched into a long dialogue.
Could you give a proper introduction before going into such a long dialogue? Well, you can introduce your characters with action or dialogue—that's fine. However, even dialogue should have something that stands out to make the reader care about your characters.
For example, by designing a humorous yet tragic voice. You do seem to try (the protagonist's sick brother makes a joke before dying). However, it feels more like a forced dark comedy, rather than born from the character's personality.
My suggestion is that you could make the hospital room scene more subtle and symbolic. There are many references you could use to build this scene... like the scene where Kaori is visited by Arima Kousei in the hospital (watch the anime Kimi no Uso).
Observe how the atmosphere is built, the dialogue between Kaori and Arima, the items they carry, and their expressions. All of this is written to narrate the conflict of the sick character. Please write a more grounded scene that will make the reader cry.
Third, your characters are more like 2D characters than living (3D) characters. It's oversimplified, as if they were more like plot devices.
Your protagonist... I don't see anything special about him. I can't identify any personality other than a character forced into a tragic situation after the death of his sibling and the betrayal of his girlfriend. And his girlfriend?
Well, she's more like a cheap villain who appears for one chapter and annoys people before disappearing (or being killed off by the plot). Her betrayal is too cheap.
Characters like this in manhua will likely regret it later, cry, and beg the MC to get back together. Why?
Because she has no personality... she's more like a plot device whose purpose is to validate the MC's future achievements. She's just a plot character, not a living character who can feel, think, have a personality, and moral values.
Please make the characters more humane... imagine the characters living in their own world, instead of characters being forced into the plot.
Fourth, you're lacking in character visualization. It's best to narrate your character's distinctive appearance through actions to make them memorable to readers.
You can describe their hair, eyes, clothing style, and even their gait, rather than simply labeling them with names.
Names are meaningless if readers can't differentiate between characters. Design iconic, easily recognizable characters.
Fifth, please format your chapters better to be mobile-friendly. Each paragraph should be 1-3 sentences long, separated by a line.
Separate dialogue between characters to easily identify who is speaking. Separate dialogue from descriptions or explanations by the narrator.
And combine dialogue with body language only to reinforce a single meaning.
Sixth, perhaps reinforce the principle of show it, don't tell it. Your narrative is still more telling than showing.
That's not wrong. However, too much telling will reduce immersion. You can create character emotions more subtly with body language, circumstances, and symbolism.
Use showing to narrate crucial moments and use telling to strengthen the narrative.
Finally, I've rambled a lot. My criticism may be biased. After all, I only read one chapter of yours, and perhaps the average reader will only read one prologue before deciding whether to continue or stop.
Please improve your narrative. Sorry if my words are too harsh. Good luck!
Regards.
Thank you — I appreciate the blunt, detailed feedback. I can see you put time into this, and I value the honesty. Your points landed, and I want you to know I’m taking them seriously.
So, to summarize what you said:
- The prologue leans on a familiar, cheap conflict (sick relative + NTR) that can turn readers off.
- Characters feel like plot devices rather than people.
- Dialogue is long and confusing; speakers aren’t clearly introduced.
- The scene tells more than it shows and uses broad metaphors instead of grounded, physical detail.
- Visual distinctiveness and mobile‑friendly formatting are weak.
And the second one: all the characters introduced here will again have importance in later chapters and be developed in more depth.
Regarding the third and fourth points, I have attempted to improve them based on your feedback, and I have included a sample scene below. The last point was a problem when I was copy‑pasting; the formatting was actually fixed on the actual chapter page.
Now, this is the sample hospital scene I tried based on what you said:
CHAPTER 0: PROLOGUE
The steady beep of the heart monitor filled the hospital room, each sound carving itself into John’s memory. The fluorescent light hummed above them. The air smelled of antiseptic and a faint, stale floral scent.
Alex, his brother, lay propped on pillows, pale but smiling. His black hair was messy, falling just short of reaching his shoulders. Dark circles rimmed his eyes; his beard was rough and unkempt but if you look closer you could glimpse at what would have once been a handsome face hidden underneath. Beside him, His favorite jacket lay folded on the chair.
“Come here, kid,” Alex said, voice rough but warm. He reached out and squeezed John’s shoulder with surprising strength. “You’ve got to stop looking like the world’s ending. I’m not gone yet.”
John moved closer without thinking, the chair scraping softly against the floor. He let Alex’s hand rest on his shoulder, feeling the tremor in Alex’s fingers as they relaxed.
John tried to smile. But It didn’t quite stick. “Yeah… you’re right. I just… I don’t know what I’d do without you.”
Alex snorted. “Oh please. You’re a grown ass man. Stop acting like I’m about to ascend into the afterlife.” He shifted, the pillow sighing under his breath. “It’s going to take a lot more than this to kill me.”
John exhaled, watching the shallow rise and fall of Alex’s chest. “That’s not very reassuring, considering you already look like you’re halfway there.” He continued chuckling a little. “Now that I take a closer look… you could actually pass for a zomb
Alex smiled, his eyes flicking away for a beat before returning. “Wow. Straight to insults. Real comforting.”
Beside John, a girl sat with silky black hair draped over one shoulder; her hazel eyes caught the light as she tilted her head, brows knitting in concern. She tucked a loose strand behind her ear and curled her fingers around John’s hand. “He’s not wrong, though. You really need a makeover.”
Alex’s smile faltered for a second, then his face twisted into a man who just suffered a stab wound. “Wow. From him, I expect nothing less. But you too Lisa?” He clutched his chest with mock drama. “My heart. Oh, you have killed me.”
John rolled his eyes . “OK, now you are just being dramatic.”
“I will be as dramatic as I want,” Alex shot back, his voice bright and loud. “How dare you insult this divine face?” He glanced at Lisa. “And especially you. I expect respect from my ‘MUCH’ younger sister-in-law.”
Lisa smiled and leaned in towards john, closing the small space between them. “Sorry but My baby comes first.”
John’s smirk was small and private, one that hinted at warmth and pride. “Well, you heard her. Honestly, it might help if you had moved on and got a girl of your own. I don’t know why you’re so hung up on that one girl.”
Alex went quiet for a beat, eyes dropping to the blanket, then lifted them again with a faint smile. “Well… forget it, you wouldn’t get it anyway.”
“Well, it was nice talking to you all, but I’m bored of you now, so you can go,” he continued, waving a hand in a lazy arc. “Meanwhile, I’ll admire my divine face.”
John shook his head. “Narcissistic much.”
Alex ignored the jab and turned his face toward Lisa; his expression softened in a way that made the room feel smaller. He leaned forward a fraction, voice gentler. “But on a more serious note, on the chance I close my eyes forever—take care of this crybaby for me. He’s a handful. Stubborn. Annoying.”
He looked at John, the words steady. “But he is my brother and doesn’t have anyone else other than you and me, so I will have to rely on you.”
Lisa’s nod came immediately. She squeezed John’s hand once, then let her fingers rest lightly along his wrist. “I will try my best.”
John’s face tightened, a shadow passing across it. He swallowed, jaw working. Alex watched him, eyes soft. “Oh, don’t start,” Alex said.
“This isn’t goodbye. It’s just… precautions.” He tried a smirk that didn’t reach his eyes. “I’ll make it. Obviously.”
John nodded, the motion small and forced, as if he were agreeing to a promise he didn’t believe. “Yeah. You’re too stubborn to die like this.”
Lisa slid her hand fully into his, thumb finding the pulse at his wrist and pressing gently. “You won’t be alone,” she whispered. “I will always be with you.”
Alex let out a short, amused sound and looked between them, the corner of his mouth lifting. “See? You’ve got someone who won’t let you drown. That’s more than most people get.”
The smile left his face as quickly as it had come. He leaned forward, lowering his voice to a conspiratorial hush. “Okay, one last thing. John, come closer. Lisa, this is a secret, so close your ears.”
John leaned in; the chair creaked beneath him. Alex’s gaze sharpened, his jaw tightening. “John, promise me. If by some miracle I die… listen to me clearly now… promise me you will delete my search history.”
John blinked, the tension in his shoulders loosening into something like relief. He let out a short laugh that shook at the edges. “Ah, grow up, you idiot. You almost gave me a heart attack there.”
Alex still held onto the serious look. “I need you to promise.”
John’s face folded into a mock solemnity for a second before cracking. “Of-course... not, hahah, I will make sure the shame follows you to the afterlife.”
Alex’s expression shifted to mock outrage, then softened into something warmer. “Wow betrayed by my own flesh and blood. Unbelievable. I practically raised you. I even changed your diapers, and this is how you repay me?”
Lisa, who had been half-listening, pushed a loose curl behind her ear and stepped a fraction closer, curiosity pulling at her features. “What are you two whispering about?”
Alex cleared his throat, a small, embarrassed sound. “Nothing important.”
John’s grin came quick and bright. “Oh, he was just asking me—”
Alex flushed, a brief color that made him look less fragile and more alive. “Hey, you little—”
Lisa laughed, the sound soft and contained. John’s smirk answered hers, and for a single breath the machines and the light and the smell of antiseptic all fell away into the background.
The monitor’s beeps kept time with their breathing. John kept his hand where Lisa held it; Alex watched them both with a look that was equal parts pride and worry. They sat like that for a moment, hands linked and small noises filling the gaps.
***
and I really appreciate the feed back