I'm SouthernMaiden, looking to give some Story Feedback while sick with the Flu [Now Closed]

SouthernMaiden

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2025
Messages
182
Points
63
Hey I'm SouthernMaiden. I'd like to give feedback on some stories.

I'll give feedback on:
  • The cover
  • The synopsis
  • And at least the first chapter

I won't be giving any scores or ratings. Also I'm too nice, so I won't tear you to shreds or anything. I'll just be honest. In this age of AI and slop I don't want to discourage any humans. :blob_cookie:
 

Eldoria

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 14, 2025
Messages
1,632
Points
113
Your title isn't provocative enough. I thought this thread was asking for feedback. It's the opposite.

Please change the title to something more direct, like "Hello! I'm a reader offering feedback to the wise author..." That way, you'll be inundated with requests until you can't breathe.

Personally, I appreciate your kindness. Regards.
 

LuciferVermillion

The sadist & madman
Joined
Nov 29, 2020
Messages
111
Points
83
Hey I'm SouthernMaiden. I'd like to give feedback on some stories.

I'll give feedback on:
  • The cover
  • The synopsis
  • And at least the first chapter

I won't be giving any scores or ratings. Also I'm too nice, so I won't tear you to shreds or anything. I'll just be honest. In this age of AI and slop I don't want to discourage any humans. :blob_cookie:
Hello. I don't mind if your feedback is harsh or tearing me to shreds.

Aside from the cover, I would like the synopsis and at least the first chapter.

https://www.scribblehub.com/series/...e-that-leads-to-a-god-of-a-new-world-volume-/
 

Macha

{$user.user_title}
Joined
Feb 6, 2021
Messages
888
Points
133
Hey I'm SouthernMaiden. I'd like to give feedback on some stories.

I'll give feedback on:
  • The cover
  • The synopsis
  • And at least the first chapter

I won't be giving any scores or ratings. Also I'm too nice, so I won't tear you to shreds or anything. I'll just be honest. In this age of AI and slop I don't want to discourage any humans. :blob_cookie:
Let me tell you something. Most new authors don't really meant it when they asked for feedbacks. They just want someone to read their stories. A self-promotion in any other name.

Your title isn't provocative enough. I thought this thread was asking for feedback. It's the opposite.

Please change the title to something more direct, like "Hello! I'm a reader offering feedback to the wise author..." That way, you'll be inundated with requests until you can't breathe.

Personally, I appreciate your kindness. Regards.
You are missing the part where you say "Can we talk in Discord? I have ideas to make your story better."
 

harrydouthwaite

Well-known member
Joined
May 4, 2023
Messages
50
Points
58
Here is my submission, I look forward to anything you have to offer...

 

Lufli

Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2026
Messages
35
Points
18
I'd be pretty happy to get some feedback on the beginning of my novel. This probably won't be the final product, so feedback is very much appreciated.



The kicks that had been raining down on him just moments ago began to fade. The screams of the men grew muffled, but their faces burned themselves into Levin’s eyes.

When he opened his eyes again, he saw nothing. Only darkness.

It wasn't clear to him what he was lying on; everything felt numb. For a moment, Levin thought he was floating—unsure if he was even still alive. Actually, there was nothing to hear but the rushing in his own brain. His attempts to move fingers, toes—anything—remained unsuccessful.

With eyes half-open, Levin forced a small smile onto his lips. Levin had no idea what kind of face he was making. How his body lay, or floated—regardless, he couldn’t help but look up. When he could no longer keep his eyes open, he closed them. There were worse things than death, if this really meant his death.

(To hell with it all...)

His inner voice wasn't agitated. Rather, it was calm, slightly optimistic. He had nothing more to lose than himself and a dirty life in a dirty city with dirty people...



When Levin came to, he wrapped his arms around himself. He got goosebumps immediately. His breath condensed before him. He straightened up slowly, first with both arms, then just with one. He balled a fist, eyebrow raised, and brushed against the hard ground he was lying on.

Stone.

When he looked up, light from the night sky fell into his eyes. It was the moon. Not quite as he knew it, as that gray, moody shapeshifter among the stars. This moon existed "here" too, but it wasn't alone.

That was also the first moment Levin realized that this place "here" couldn't be Earth.

The familiar moon hung in the night sky—Levin believed he could recognize it in any world, as often as he’d seen it—but below it hung two others. One glowed blue-green. Levin knew the color from his visit to the sea. In his hometown, it was always a myth what such a thing looked like, but Levin had been allowed to see it! The sea.

It wasn't as blue as Levin had thought—partly, yes—but it reflected in many colors, especially green, which perhaps came from all the trash lying in it. A greasy substance floated on the surface, providing all the colors of the rainbow. It was ugly. Still, he thanked his gang leader in Gorra—back on Earth—for taking him there.

The other moon, however, was black. A cut in the sky that Levin only saw because of the surrounding stars. Levin narrowed his eyes as he inspected the sky. His body froze, his face twisting.

(This isn't Gorra... This can't be Earth, right?! Was I marked, too? I didn't show any symptoms, what a load of crap!)

As Levin checked his own body for damage or missing limbs, and especially for the mark, his body shuddered once more. The mark was hard to miss. Only now did it start to itch.

Beneath Levin’s torn clothes, stitched together from scraps of fabric, the mark lay on his skin like coal. It painted the ribs beneath his right pectoral black without shame. Levin craned his head back to grasp the extent of this stain. Levin's right side was stained from near his navel to just before his spine, with a few tendril-like sweeps at the borders.

Levin knew what a mark meant. When a mark appeared on humans, they vanished from Earth after three days—or so the stories went; Levin didn't believe in myths.

Levin ran his hand over the mark, eyes wide. It pulsed slightly, but the sensation echoed through his entire body. Levin's hand twitched, as if it wanted to scrape the mark off, skin and all. Levin jerked his hand away. It was as if his hand had developed its own consciousness that wanted to drive out everything foreign—and the mark definitely belonged to that category.

(Careful now...)

When wandering in strange lands, one had to be careful, above all else. Shortly after, the black tendrils on his skin swayed minimally and immediately retreated to their original position.

Somehow, Levin saw everything very clearly. Too clearly. At every movement, his head jerked almost mechanically, picking up movements or sounds Levin had never heard or seen before. The light of the moons flickered briefly, as if something flew through it. It left a whistling vibration in the air.

Levin removed his hand from the mark again—it’s probably best not to mess with it, he thought. First things first: know exactly where I am. Find water and food.

Levin's legs obeyed his thoughts and they were not disfigured, as he initially assumed. That must have been a dream or a place between the two worlds. But he was sure that those men on Earth had beaten him crippled, literally.

(But everything’s back in place!)

This made Levin's eyes go wide. His head swiveled left and right. To the left, a narrow hole led to the night sky. Around the hole was stone.

(A cave, then...)

Levin walked along the cave wall with one hand outstretched. And he did so even though he could see everything clearly, despite the night sky. Outside the cave, a small platform extended out, but it led into nothingness. A cliff that dropped hundreds of meters into the depths.

Saliva forced its way down Levin’s throat at the sight. His body froze, as well as his blue eyes, which just seemed empty.

He looked back up at the three moons. He had to shield his eyes with his hand, as if their light blinded like the sun. And realized—he had escaped. The shithole that called itself Gorra lay behind him.

An open land, completely unknown, lay before him. Never before had Levin felt so free that he spread his arms, as if to fly along with the night breeze. But his arms couldn’t reach beyond their own length. Still, his heart beat a little faster; he didn't even notice his own shallow hyperventilation. He also missed the small, contented smile on his face.

(Where have I ended up?) wondered Levin.
 

LeilaniOtter

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 29, 2025
Messages
1,188
Points
113
I'd be pretty happy to get some feedback on the beginning of my novel. This probably won't be the final product, so feedback is very much appreciated.



The kicks that had been raining down on him just moments ago began to fade. The screams of the men grew muffled, but their faces burned themselves into Levin’s eyes.

When he opened his eyes again, he saw nothing. Only darkness.

It wasn't clear to him what he was lying on; everything felt numb. For a moment, Levin thought he was floating—unsure if he was even still alive. Actually, there was nothing to hear but the rushing in his own brain. His attempts to move fingers, toes—anything—remained unsuccessful.

With eyes half-open, Levin forced a small smile onto his lips. Levin had no idea what kind of face he was making. How his body lay, or floated—regardless, he couldn’t help but look up. When he could no longer keep his eyes open, he closed them. There were worse things than death, if this really meant his death.

(To hell with it all...)

His inner voice wasn't agitated. Rather, it was calm, slightly optimistic. He had nothing more to lose than himself and a dirty life in a dirty city with dirty people...



When Levin came to, he wrapped his arms around himself. He got goosebumps immediately. His breath condensed before him. He straightened up slowly, first with both arms, then just with one. He balled a fist, eyebrow raised, and brushed against the hard ground he was lying on.

Stone.

When he looked up, light from the night sky fell into his eyes. It was the moon. Not quite as he knew it, as that gray, moody shapeshifter among the stars. This moon existed "here" too, but it wasn't alone.

That was also the first moment Levin realized that this place "here" couldn't be Earth.

The familiar moon hung in the night sky—Levin believed he could recognize it in any world, as often as he’d seen it—but below it hung two others. One glowed blue-green. Levin knew the color from his visit to the sea. In his hometown, it was always a myth what such a thing looked like, but Levin had been allowed to see it! The sea.

It wasn't as blue as Levin had thought—partly, yes—but it reflected in many colors, especially green, which perhaps came from all the trash lying in it. A greasy substance floated on the surface, providing all the colors of the rainbow. It was ugly. Still, he thanked his gang leader in Gorra—back on Earth—for taking him there.

The other moon, however, was black. A cut in the sky that Levin only saw because of the surrounding stars. Levin narrowed his eyes as he inspected the sky. His body froze, his face twisting.

(This isn't Gorra... This can't be Earth, right?! Was I marked, too? I didn't show any symptoms, what a load of crap!)

As Levin checked his own body for damage or missing limbs, and especially for the mark, his body shuddered once more. The mark was hard to miss. Only now did it start to itch.

Beneath Levin’s torn clothes, stitched together from scraps of fabric, the mark lay on his skin like coal. It painted the ribs beneath his right pectoral black without shame. Levin craned his head back to grasp the extent of this stain. Levin's right side was stained from near his navel to just before his spine, with a few tendril-like sweeps at the borders.

Levin knew what a mark meant. When a mark appeared on humans, they vanished from Earth after three days—or so the stories went; Levin didn't believe in myths.

Levin ran his hand over the mark, eyes wide. It pulsed slightly, but the sensation echoed through his entire body. Levin's hand twitched, as if it wanted to scrape the mark off, skin and all. Levin jerked his hand away. It was as if his hand had developed its own consciousness that wanted to drive out everything foreign—and the mark definitely belonged to that category.

(Careful now...)

When wandering in strange lands, one had to be careful, above all else. Shortly after, the black tendrils on his skin swayed minimally and immediately retreated to their original position.

Somehow, Levin saw everything very clearly. Too clearly. At every movement, his head jerked almost mechanically, picking up movements or sounds Levin had never heard or seen before. The light of the moons flickered briefly, as if something flew through it. It left a whistling vibration in the air.

Levin removed his hand from the mark again—it’s probably best not to mess with it, he thought. First things first: know exactly where I am. Find water and food.

Levin's legs obeyed his thoughts and they were not disfigured, as he initially assumed. That must have been a dream or a place between the two worlds. But he was sure that those men on Earth had beaten him crippled, literally.

(But everything’s back in place!)

This made Levin's eyes go wide. His head swiveled left and right. To the left, a narrow hole led to the night sky. Around the hole was stone.

(A cave, then...)

Levin walked along the cave wall with one hand outstretched. And he did so even though he could see everything clearly, despite the night sky. Outside the cave, a small platform extended out, but it led into nothingness. A cliff that dropped hundreds of meters into the depths.

Saliva forced its way down Levin’s throat at the sight. His body froze, as well as his blue eyes, which just seemed empty.

He looked back up at the three moons. He had to shield his eyes with his hand, as if their light blinded like the sun. And realized—he had escaped. The shithole that called itself Gorra lay behind him.

An open land, completely unknown, lay before him. Never before had Levin felt so free that he spread his arms, as if to fly along with the night breeze. But his arms couldn’t reach beyond their own length. Still, his heart beat a little faster; he didn't even notice his own shallow hyperventilation. He also missed the small, contented smile on his face.

(Where have I ended up?) wondered Levin.
Curious, is this a translation at all...?
 

LeilaniOtter

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 29, 2025
Messages
1,188
Points
113
It is. I'm not a native speaker so I write the draft in my native language and then translate it, to some extent at least. I'm working on my english writing. (I accidentally clicked reply twice, dont know how to undo it :))
It's okay, it's just that I could see shades of AI throughout as I read. ? Keep working. This looks okay, but just try and spot where the AI came into play and suggest re-writing a little bit, so it looks more...you. ?
 

Lufli

Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2026
Messages
35
Points
18
It's okay, it's just that I could see shades of AI throughout as I read. ? Keep working. This looks okay, but just try and spot where the AI came into play and suggest re-writing a little bit, so it looks more...you. ?
As you might have noticed, I'm not very experienced. I'd love to know,
where you saw the traces of AI. And should I ask AI for feedback? Sometimes I'm happy with a scene, but AI tells me its bad.
 

LeilaniOtter

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 29, 2025
Messages
1,188
Points
113
As you might have noticed, I'm not very experienced. I'd love to know,
where you saw the traces of AI. And should I ask AI for feedback? Sometimes I'm happy with a scene, but AI tells me its bad.
Well, the first thing I would do, if I were you, is to tell AI to go fuck itself, sideways if possible.

The second thing you should do is pick up Strunk and White's "The Elements of Style" and just start reading and digesting everything you can. Get so well versed in this book, it is a writer's greatest treasure.

Then go back to AI, tell it how well you did without it, and to fuck itself again. ?
 

J_Win

Active member
Joined
Jun 13, 2024
Messages
31
Points
33
Welp, I have nothing to lose


(Idk if you count prologue as a first chapter but, I hope it is at least entertaining)
 

Lufli

Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2026
Messages
35
Points
18
Well, the first thing I would do, if I were you, is to tell AI to go fuck itself, sideways if possible.

The second thing you should do is pick up Strunk and White's "The Elements of Style" and just start reading and digesting everything you can. Get so well versed in this book, it is a writer's greatest treasure.

Then go back to AI, tell it how well you did without it, and to fuck itself again. ?
Hahahha.
I'll definetily check out Strunk and White. Thank you for your time.
 

SouthernMaiden

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2025
Messages
182
Points
63
Hello. I don't mind if your feedback is harsh or tearing me to shreds.

Aside from the cover, I would like the synopsis and at least the first chapter.

https://www.scribblehub.com/series/...e-that-leads-to-a-god-of-a-new-world-volume-/
Synopsis:

-This is a lot. Personally, I would cut several elements.
-Pick a few important things you want to convey, get rid of the rest.

Prologue:
-The prologue is also a lot for a new reader, it's overwhelming.
-Why are some words like this "<Principal>". Are these titles?

Chapter 1:

My main piece of feedback is that the reader is inundated with concepts, characters and the story starts with the MC already imprisoned on an island for reasons we don't quite understand. It’s risky to start a story like this; you have to keep everyone engaged until they can learn what’s going on. Is there a better way to give us this information, to bring us into the world in a way that’s less overwhelming?

-We have: 20 Seals, magical backlash, catkin, magical pets, a fingerprint scanning phone, an accident two years ago, the bermuda triangle. A date showing that it takes place in the 80s. And that's just the first chapter, include the prologue and it gets a bit crazy.

It’s competently written, but you do overuse the single sentence per line thing.
Let me tell you something. Most new authors don't really meant it when they asked for feedbacks. They just want someone to read their stories. A self-promotion in any other name.


You are missing the part where you say "Can we talk in Discord? I have ideas to make your story better."
I'm stuck at home with the flu, I don't mind reading stuff. As long as it's not AI. I'm in a weird mood where I want to immerse myself in human creativity.
 
Last edited:

CinnaSloth

Sinful Sloth
Joined
Nov 20, 2024
Messages
522
Points
108
I'll throw my hat into the ring. sure.

Ise-se-Kai 20
Which is something I think people are enjoying reading based off engagement, though, I'd really like some feedback on why, or for what reason. I'm not a big fan of the Isekai genre, but figured I had a funny idea. The Real Title is in the synopsis. I think it'll tell you everything you need to know about this one, but I promise it's a real story, not just complete satire. :blob_nom:
&
My Little Sister, The Dark Lord
Which will unforgivingly throw you under a bus, and spit on the remains of squishy goodness afterward, probably having you wonder why you opened this books pages in the first place. lmao YAY! YIPPIE!! This one is a fully imagined story, but mostly satire. It is incredibly niche. Warnings are in the synopsis. Goodluck, I doubt you'll get far. Is that a challenge? Maybe. :blob_evil:
 

SouthernMaiden

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2025
Messages
182
Points
63
Here is my submission, I look forward to anything you have to offer...

Synopsis:

- Too long and it doesn't summarize enough, looks like a wall of text

Chapter 1:
-Add horizontal lines to separate the parts
-Some of the paragraphs are too long, split them up
-Not the typical subject matter for a web novel, seems to be aimed at a younger audience. Personally, not my cup of tea.
-It could use a good edit for conciseness in places.

Overall, kinda wholesome. Reminds me of something I might have read in school.
I'd love to receive feedback. I'm My Own High School Rival
Synopsis:

-Too long. Especially since it spaced out with one sentence per line in places.
-I would make this way shorter and focused.

Chapter 1:
  • -”My skin, light brown instead of white, was youthful as I traced my arm up to my shoulder and to my face.” At first I thought you were saying that white is “default”, and not that they were white in their past life.
  • Repetitive and overly descriptive wording in places: “Rays” “Lull” “lavender” “Blinding” “warm”, these words come up often enough for me to notice.
  • Another example of being overly descriptive: “—her voice honeyed.” The dialogue itself is mostly showing what her tone would be, I’m not sure we need the clarification.
  • Some of the paragraphing and formatting could be better, especially with how the dialogue is integrated. It’s difficult to explain, take a look at some of the top stories to see how they do it.
  • I don’t know what this means: I mean, this face wouldn’t win a stare-down in holding or get me a smoke in the yard, without favors.

Overall, I think it’s too wordy and overly descriptive sometimes. Also, I find myself wanting a stronger hook to keep me reading to the next chapter. I didn’t hate it though, just fixing some of the formatting would improve it a lot.
You already helped me once soooooooo...
Novel: Cursed Hand: With Simple Curses, I Annihilated Everything Using the [Cursed Hand] | Scribble Hub
For the cover, you won't need to bother. I'm not good at art and broke so I just used Canvas to make a cover
Synopsis:

- I would split this into two shorter paragraphs

Chapter 1:
  • You overdue the one sentence per line thing. Don’t be afraid to write a simple short paragraph. As an example, this passage is formatted 1 sentence per line. I think this could be done better:
“I thankfully still had my bedclothes, but it felt weird being surrounded by these people who looked like they were from the past.

Even the world outside the windows didn't look form my time.

If I had to compare, it would be Victorian America, which was ironic since I com form America.

Yeah, despite having a Japanese name, I was American.

Mother was Japanese and father was America.

She moved her for the typical reasons.

Job opportunities and freedom, just like America promised.

As they brought me along, I noticed the halls were definitely not in my apartment.”
Also, while editing and rereading chapters before publishing ask yourself:
  • Am I showing instead of telling? Would it be stronger if I showed instead of told?
  • Could this be more concise? Does this sentence or description serve a purpose?
For example, the serial killer. You write his body count. Does it have to be here?

You also tell us he’s a cannibal, looks like a sociopath, has a psychotic voice, is on deathrow, and you tell us that he looks unhinged. Do we need all of this here? And do we also need his body count here? Maybe he could brag about it later when threatening the protag or something…

Two more points:
  • Was this inspired by the manga Failure Frame?
  • I would also say that it needs an additional review to catch some errors
 
Last edited:

MakBow

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 31, 2025
Messages
292
Points
63
Synopsis:

- Too long and it doesn't summarize enough, looks like a wall of text

Chapter 1:
-Add horizontal lines to separate the parts
-Some of the paragraphs are too long, split them up
-Not the typical subject matter for a web novel, seems to be aimed at a younger audience. Personally, not my cup of tea.
-It could use a good edit for conciseness in places.

Overall, kinda wholesome. Reminds me of something I might have read in school.

Synopsis:

-Too long. Especially since it spaced out with one sentence per line in places.
-I would make this way shorter and focused.

Chapter 1:
  • -”My skin, light brown instead of white, was youthful as I traced my arm up to my shoulder and to my face.” At first I thought you were saying that white is “default”, and not that they were white in their past life.
  • Repetitive and overly descriptive wording in places: “Rays” “Lull” “lavender” “Blinding” “warm”, these words come up often enough for me to notice.
  • Another example of being overly descriptive: “—her voice honeyed.” The dialogue itself is mostly showing what her tone would be, I’m not sure we need the clarification.
  • Some of the paragraphing and formatting could be better, especially with how the dialogue is integrated. It’s difficult to explain, take a look at some of the top stories to see how they do it.
  • I don’t know what this means: I mean, this face wouldn’t win a stare-down in holding or get me a smoke in the yard, without favors.

Overall, I think it’s too wordy and overly descriptive sometimes. Also, I find myself wanting a stronger hook to keep me reading to the next chapter. I didn’t hate it though, just fixing some of the formatting would improve it a lot.

Synopsis:

- I would split this into two shorter paragraphs

Chapter 1:
  • You overdue the one sentence per line thing. Don’t be afraid to write a simple short paragraph. As an example, this passage is formatted 1 sentence per line. I think this could be done better:

Also, while editing and rereading chapters before publishing ask yourself:
  • Am I showing instead of telling? Would it be stronger if I showed instead of told?
  • Could this be more concise? Does this sentence or description serve a purpose?
For example, the serial killer. You write his body count. Does it have to be here?

You also tell us he’s a cannibal, looks like a sociopath, has a psychotic voice, is on deathrow, and you tell us that he looks unhinged. Do we need all of this here? And do we also need his body count here? Maybe he could brag about it later when threatening the protag or something…

Two more points:
  • Was this inspired by the manga Failure Frame?
  • I would also say that it needs an additional review to catch some errors
Yes, it indeed was inspired by Failure Frame and thank you for the feedback
 
Top