Account banned by mistake – request for review”

Status
Not open for further replies.

orchidplanet

New member
Joined
Sep 24, 2025
Messages
2
Points
1
Hello ScribbleHub staff,

My account was recently banned and I believe this may have been a mistake.
I only posted my story *Gam’lor* and exchanged some messages in the inbox.
I didn’t do anything against the rules, so I kindly ask for a review of my account.

Thank you for your time and support!
 

Dec

The Evil Mage
Joined
Nov 4, 2022
Messages
658
Points
133
Looking at the story... I can easily guess why you were banned.


1758832259949.png
 

orchidplanet

New member
Joined
Sep 24, 2025
Messages
2
Points
1
Forget coherence; it's amazing how AI can't even be consistent

I understand your point, but I assure you my story isn’t just random AI output. I work on each chapter carefully, revising and editing until it fits the vision I have for Gam’lor. Sometimes the style might shift because I’m experimenting with ways to make the scenes hit harder, but that’s part of growing as a writer. I appreciate the feedback—it motivates me to polish my work even more."
Thank you for the clarification. I understand now that something in my story may have been flagged, but I’m still not fully sure what part specifically violated the guidelines. The fragment you showed me was meant only as a market scene with some tension, not to cross into graphic or harmful content.

If it’s an issue of tone or phrasing, I’m more than willing to revise and adjust my chapters to fit within Scribble Hub’s rules. My intention is only to tell a fantasy story, not to break any guidelines.

Could you please let me know which exact element needs to be changed so I can correct it? I’d really appreciate the chance to fix the problem instead of losing the whole account.

Thank you for your time and guidance.
 
Last edited:

Dec

The Evil Mage
Joined
Nov 4, 2022
Messages
658
Points
133
Wonder how the stories got approved on the first place. Who even approve stories these days?
Sadly, approval doesn't mean verification. Especially as you can get the story approved before you add first chapter.

From my knowledge, there is a mix between automatic and manual approval by Tony.
 

Macha

{$user.user_title}
Joined
Feb 6, 2021
Messages
888
Points
133
Sadly, approval doesn't mean verification. Especially as you can get the story approved before you add first chapter.

From my knowledge, there is a mix between automatic and manual approval by Tony.
Using clankers to approve or disapprove stories written by clankers. Smart.

Modern problems require modern solutions.
 

Dec

The Evil Mage
Joined
Nov 4, 2022
Messages
658
Points
133
So, AI can be used, huh?

Can one use an AI cover only?
It can be used, yes. But can't write for you the majority of the text (which, in my opinion, is already too much).
Covers are outside of this; you can use AI gen for them as much as you want. This point is only for the writing part.
 

Max02

Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2025
Messages
56
Points
18
Is there some software that detects whether AI was used 100% or only partially?
 

Dec

The Evil Mage
Joined
Nov 4, 2022
Messages
658
Points
133
Is there some software that detects whether AI was used 100% or only partially?
Yes. It's called "eyes of experienced readers."
Anyone that read enough books in their past is more than good enough to distinguish when LLM was used and on what scale. It's impossible to miss those patterns.
 
Last edited:

Max02

Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2025
Messages
56
Points
18
Was this written by AI?

"Another word T.X.U.-6689 remembered learning from a very early age was ultimus. What was an ultimus? The exact opposite of Unus. Ultimus was any being that had descended, for whatever reason, to the ultimate level a creature could reach. While Unus knew and saw everything, was everywhere, ultimus knew nothing, saw nothing, could do nothing, and was nowhere; he was simply a being transformed into a non-being. T.X.U.-6689 learned from an early age that he could never even come close to being like Unus, the perfect being, the infallible being, but neither should he aspire to be like ultimus, to become an ultimus. To avoid becoming an ultimus, a non-being, he must strictly follow the path of wisdom. This path involved, of course, the understanding that Unus knows and can do everything. And that Unus's representative among the Terraunans was Primus. Primus, that wonderful voice he'd grown accustomed to hearing from such a young age. Primus had no face, at least not a face a normal Terraunan could or deserved to see. But Primus had a voice, and what a voice! A voice both powerful and delicate, lofty and gentle, a tone above being tiresome, a tone below being irritating. The perfect voice, the voice everyone aspired to have, but only Primus had. Hearing his words of wisdom at the end of each day was the most sublime moment of a Terraunan's life."
 

Corty

Ra’Coon
Joined
Oct 7, 2022
Messages
4,680
Points
183
Another word T.X.U.-6689 remembered learning from a very early age was ultimus. What was an ultimus? The exact opposite of Unus. Ultimus was any being that had descended, for whatever reason, to the ultimate level a creature could reach. While Unus knew and saw everything, was everywhere, ultimus knew nothing, saw nothing, could do nothing, and was nowhere; he was simply a being transformed into a non-being. T.X.U.-6689 learned from an early age that he could never even come close to being like Unus, the perfect being, the infallible being, but neither should he aspire to be like ultimus, to become an ultimus. To avoid becoming an ultimus, a non-being, he must strictly follow the path of wisdom. This path involved, of course, the understanding that Unus knows and can do everything. And that Unus's representative among the Terraunans was Primus. Primus, that wonderful voice he'd grown accustomed to hearing from such a young age. Primus had no face, at least not a face a normal Terraunan could or deserved to see. But Primus had a voice, and what a voice! A voice both powerful and delicate, lofty and gentle, a tone above being tiresome, a tone below being irritating. The perfect voice, the voice everyone aspired to have, but only Primus had. Hearing his words of wisdom at the end of each day was the most sublime moment of a Terraunan's life
If the AI is Yevgeny Zamyatin, then yes.

By the way, fuck off with your nitpicking.
 

Max02

Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2025
Messages
56
Points
18
Never even read anything by Zamyatin before, but ok.

How am I nitpicking?
 

Max02

Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2025
Messages
56
Points
18
Lol, I was asking a mod (?) if he could tell whether the text was written by AI or not. He said that his eyes can tell it from a distance. How is this nitpicking? Aren't we here to talk about this kind of thing??
 

RepresentingWrath

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
13,556
Points
283
Lol, I was asking a mod
Dec is not a mod.
Aren't we here to talk about this kind of thing??
No, this thread is not about, "how can we distinguish if a text is written by AI or not?" This thread is about user asking a question, why they got banned. He or she got an answer. If you are interested in all those things you ask, you should make a separate thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top