Warning: I have a few concept ideas for your character. Want to share?

Paul__Michaels

Just a below average author.
Joined
Feb 9, 2023
Messages
542
Points
133
So, this is a warning for any new authors out there who receive a direct message like this one. This "reader" says they like my work and can't wait to read more. Upon checking their account, they don't have any of my books on their reading list. They don't comment on anyone else's books; however, they follow over 100 authors. Strange, right? It's only after how they respond to me that everything clicks into place. This dude is a so-called "artist," and they have "a few concept ideas for my character," and they want to share them with me.

Oh, boy! The Red Flags are sticking out to this guy like a fucking pincushion.

Red Flag #1: They don't say which character they have ideas for.
I have multiple books. And them being vague is a sign that they haven't read shit. If they truly cared about your novel, book, or series, then they would have brought up one of your characters' names.

Red Flag #2: Zero Comments, but follows over 100 authors.
This is a sign that they just hop on to see who's recently posted on the site and follow a author to direct a message to them later. I wouldn't be surprised if everyone on this guy's follow list has received a message from him with a similar vague "Nice work" to get you to respond. They got me, so it works.

Red Flag #3: They have no obvious portfolio.
If someone is an artist, they would have something to show their work. This guy has jack shit on his account page.

Red Flag #4: They've only been a member for a few days or months.
This guy is in the months category, so he's slyer than most. It isn't definitive, but it is definitely a sign that they create a lot of accounts.

Red Flag #5: An "Artist" is coming to you.
Think about this. You are either a hobbyist, an amateur, or a nobody author, and someone comes up to you and says they love your work so much that they are inspired by it, to the extent that they would love to create art for you. It's, of course, commission-based art—no free rides for you, good sir or madam. They don't care about your work; they care about siphoning money from inexperienced writers while giving you inferior quality art and not doing what you requested. You are better off using AI-generated art than these assholes because they might be using AI Art anyway, so cut out the middleman. And if you want a real artist, then do your research and reach out to one of them.

So, why am I making such a big stink out of this? Because guys like Erik12 are slyer than those idiots who post a comment on a chapter of your work. It's far more apparent that those people are scam artists than people like Erik12. And it annoys the shit out of me that they get money out of hobbyists.

Anyway, I wanted to vent, and this is more of a PSA for new authors than anything else, because it must work to have this many scam artists of late.

That is all.
A_Few_Concept_Ideas.jpg

Eirk12Page.jpg
 

Attachments

  • A_Few_Concept_Ideas.jpg
    A_Few_Concept_Ideas.jpg
    651.4 KB · Views: 37
Last edited:

Paul__Michaels

Just a below average author.
Joined
Feb 9, 2023
Messages
542
Points
133
I'm wondering if he's going to respond. I doubt it, but I'll update if he does. :blob_popcorn:
 
D

Deleted member 166465

Guest
I always assume everyone is a bot... or a scammer... problem solved.
 

ArchlordZero

Stage 4 Cancer Shitposter
Joined
Aug 10, 2020
Messages
328
Points
133
Strangely enough, I only get these comments in Wattpad.
It's way easier to track them there because they will comment on my latest chapters (150+) right after they followed my profile.
Sometimes, they will say they have idea for my novel.
 

Hans.Trondheim

Low energy is king!
Joined
Jan 22, 2021
Messages
1,985
Points
153
So, this is a warning for any new authors out there who receive a direct message like this one. This "reader" says they like my work and can't wait to read more. Upon checking their account, they don't have any of my books on their reading list. They don't comment on anyone else's books; however, they follow over 100 authors. Strange, right? It's only after how they respond to me that everything clicks into place. This dude is a so-called "artist," and they have "a few concept ideas for my character," and they want to share them with me.

Oh, boy! The Red Flags are sticking out to this guy like a fucking pincushion.

Red Flag #1: They don't say which character they have ideas for.
I have multiple books. And them being vague is a sign that they haven't read shit. If they truly cared about your novel, book, or series, then they would have brought up one of your characters' names.

Red Flag #2: Zero Comments, but follows over 100 authors.
This is a sign that they just hop on to see who's recently posted on the site and follow a author to direct a message to them later. I wouldn't be surprised if everyone on this guy's follow list has received a message from him with a similar vague "Nice work" to get you to respond. They got me, so it works.

Red Flag #3: They have no obvious portfolio.
If someone is an artist, they would have something to show their work. This guy has jack shit on his account page.

Red Flag #4: They've only been a member for a few days or months.
This guy is in the months category, so he's slyer than most. It isn't definitive, but it is definitely a sign that they create a lot of accounts.

Red Flag #5: An "Artist" is coming to you.
Think about this. You are either a hobbyist, an amateur, or a nobody author, and someone comes up to you and says they love your work so much that they are inspired by it, to the extent that they would love to create art for you. It's, of course, commission-based art—no free rides for you, good sir or madam. They don't care about your work; they care about siphoning money from inexperienced writers while giving you inferior quality art and not doing what you requested. You are better off using AI-generated art than these assholes because they might be using AI Art anyway, so cut out the middleman. And if you want a real artist, then do your research and reach out to one of them.

So, why am I making such a big stink out of this? Because guys like Erik12 are slyer than those idiots who post a comment on a chapter of your work. It's far more apparent that those people are scam artists than people like Erik12. And it annoys the shit out of me that they get money out of hobbyists.

Anyway, I wanted to vent, and this is more of a PSA for new authors than anything else, because it must work to have this many scam artists of late.

That is all.
View attachment 40921
I see you're also pissed off.

Here's mine. This fker sent me an email, too, back when I was expecting an important mail.
 

Paul__Michaels

Just a below average author.
Joined
Feb 9, 2023
Messages
542
Points
133
I see you're also pissed off.

Here's mine. This fker sent me an email, too, back when I was expecting an important mail.
Yeah. I remember that thread. I wouldn't say I'm pissed. I'm more frustrated that I wasn't talking to a fan. Because it comes off as a possible fan only to find out that he's a fraud. Good warm feelings are gone :blob_teary:
Strangely enough, I only get these comments in Wattpad.
It's way easier to track them there because they will comment on my latest chapters (150+) right after they followed my profile.
Sometimes, they will say they have idea for my novel.
It makes me wonder if that is the reason why Wattpad got rid of the direct messaging on their site. But yeah, these messages are a dime of dozen on their.
 

RepresentingWrath

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
13,556
Points
283
It makes me wonder if that is the reason why Wattpad got rid of the direct messaging on their site. But yeah, these messages are a dime of dozen on their.
You have to get rid of comments as well, DMs are not the only place where they appear in SH. Although it is easier to moderate comments, it is still frustrating I presume.
 
Top