Introducing an annoying character (that I like)

expentio

Well-known member
Joined
May 8, 2019
Messages
350
Points
103
Yeah, a bit of an issue, I'd like to discuss. Well, essentially I'm mostly complaining about my dilemma. I'm going to introduce a character in my long time story (over 150 chapters, doing well) that I personally quite like. Yet I fear there might be a bit of backlash. The raw chapters are basically already written, so it'ts going to happen anyway.
Essentially, the new character is a cosmic agent of order who's sent to basically shackle my MC who's an eldritch world devourer. Okay, she's a bit too nice to actually do so, but the fact that she can means that the upper orders at least want her contained. Now essentially the cosmic cop is super chill. She's not too violent, asks her politely, of course gets refused, and then it starts. The main thing, aside from being a pain to the MC, is that she actually is powerful enough to get through with it. So next to opposing the MC, she's also going to put a huge downer on what essentially might be a power fantasy. While the MC had her fair share of troubles at this point, she is in many cases still the biggest fish, so getting put into place by a cop is a bit of a damper. Furthermore, that cop isn't even alone. She got a being she's working for who's even worse. And I mean that in the best sense, as I like that character as well. Basically, they are original characters I created long before even starting my story and now I got presented with the opportunity to actually let them have their turn as well. But as I said, they have quite the ungrateful job, given what they have to do. (it won't have actually negative consequences for the MC, but it's still a bit worse than a mere warning)
I guess this post is mostly me testing out the feedback water.
 

GlassRose

Kaleidoscope of Harmonious Contradiction
Joined
Apr 20, 2021
Messages
405
Points
133
You're going to have mixed reactions if you go through with it. That's not necessarily a bad thing.

It ultimately comes down to you. Why are you writing this story? Is it because you want people to enjoy it? Or is it because this is a story that you like, and want to tell? Of course, it's probably a bit of both. You have to decide which you care more about. Or to put it another way, which will hurt you least. Is it going to hurt you more to compromise your ideals for this story for the sake of catering to your readers? Or is it going to hurt you more to recieve mixed reactions, have some readers feel like their expectations were betrayed? There is no universal right answer, just what is most important to you. Choose whichever you think you'll regret the least.
 

TASTYLEADPAINT

Resident Tech priest
Joined
Aug 10, 2020
Messages
602
Points
133
It's a tough spot you're in but like the comment above its up to what you want. I would personally write it as i want it because it's my story.

If you do plan to do this I would do what the author of gushing about magical girls did. Try to end every fight between the opposing sides end in a satisfying draw. But I feel that may be a cop out.
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,725
Points
158
How annoying are the characters - and, are they annoying to the READER or just to the MC? If they just annoy the MC, they can be a great source of either comedy or tension for the reader. If they annoy the READER then you may lose some.
 

expentio

Well-known member
Joined
May 8, 2019
Messages
350
Points
103
How annoying are the characters - and, are they annoying to the READER or just to the MC? If they just annoy the MC, they can be a great source of either comedy or tension for the reader. If they annoy the READER then you may lose some.
I guess that's mostly subjective, but I can tell that the new character is actually so annoying to reach her goal that they non-violently get my pazifist MC to lash out and start a fight.
Also, the higher up of the cosmic agent is going to come down and settlè this. At this point, my "power fantasy" MC is going to be so highly outclassed that they can't quite negotiate about the shackle anymore.
Actually, it's not so much a shackle and more of a blaring alarm siren (to herself and the higher being), that goes on whenever she is about to break cosmic rules like eating protected worlds.
It's gonna be a reminder that the MC isn't quite the pinnacle she was appearing as till this point, even if the rules might be reasonable.
 

CharlesEBrown

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2024
Messages
4,725
Points
158
I guess that's mostly subjective, but I can tell that the new character is actually so annoying to reach her goal that they non-violently get my pazifist MC to lash out and start a fight.
Also, the higher up of the cosmic agent is going to come down and settlè this. At this point, my "power fantasy" MC is going to be so highly outclassed that they can't quite negotiate about the shackle anymore.

It's gonna be a reminder that the MC isn't quite the pinnacle she was appearing as till this point, even if the rules might be reasonable.
That does not sound like it would be a problem for most readers. Might tick off the power fantasy crowd I hear exists on RR but otherwise, eh.
 

MarekSusicky

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 18, 2020
Messages
154
Points
83
:blob_cookie: That sounds very exciting! If I were you I would stick with it, sounds really awesome! If it makes the most sense for the story reader *can* forgive annoying things. Sometimes. Anyway, good luck :blob_salute:
 

corruption

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 14, 2024
Messages
204
Points
58
From what I can tell from the chapter length mentioned and description, I am guessing you are talking about Isekai'd Shoggoth.
Have her introduction make sense.
I would recommend this:
The MC is an agent of Chaos, have the cop enter as an agent of Order to restore balance, and if that means opposing the MC, then it happens.
The fact the MC is causing chaos while at the same time doing good would cause issues. How do you maintain Balance while fighting against the very force of chaos that is helping people like she is without causing a lot of Chaos and problems yourself?
 

expentio

Well-known member
Joined
May 8, 2019
Messages
350
Points
103
From what I can tell from the chapter length mentioned and description, I am guessing you are talking about Isekai'd Shoggoth.
Have her introduction make sense.
I would recommend this:
The MC is an agent of Chaos, have the cop enter as an agent of Order to restore balance, and if that means opposing the MC, then it happens.
The fact the MC is causing chaos while at the same time doing good would cause issues. How do you maintain Balance while fighting against the very force of chaos that is helping people like she is without causing a lot of Chaos and problems yourself?
Nah, I'm not the author of this. My story is just called Eldritch:


Yet I think it does decently well.
 

corruption

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 14, 2024
Messages
204
Points
58
Nah, I'm not the author of this. My story is just called Eldritch:


Yet I think it does decently well.
I'll have to read it when I have the time.
Still, I like the idea of an agent of Order causing chaos as they try to apprehend a being of Chaos who just wants a nice Orderly life.
 
Top